Overall audio performance for the G430 is mediocre. There
are no tonal characteristics which jump to mind when first listening to the
headset. While there are no glaring flaws with the audio rendition of tracks,
such as Hotel California by the Eagles, the experience is unfortunately
forgettable. The G430 comes with Dolby Headphone technology but no Dolby Pro
Logic Ilx. The 7.1 virtual surround sound effect while gaming is not an
expansive as the other headsets tested. It is difficult to accurately pinpoint the
source of the sound and the direction it is coming from with the G430. Simply
put, the G430 cannot seriously compete with the rest in this shootout in terms
of raw gaming audio performance.
Roccat Kulo
Founded in 2007, Roccat is a relative new-corner to the
gaming peripherals market. At present their product ranges include keyboards,
mice and gaming headsets, of which the last category is represented by the Kulo
gaming headset.
Roccat Kulo
Barring this ROCCat gaming headset, all other contenders in
this shootout come with a circumaural design. The Kulo 7.1 however sports a
supra-aural wearing style. The choice of on-ear design means that the Roccat
gaming headset is dwarfed in size when compared with the others. That said, the
Kulo's build quality is excellent. The Kulo comes in black, with small blue
Roccat signage on the ear-cups and a sliver of silver on the headband.
The supra-aural wearing style and a low contact pressure
help the Kulo be very comfortable. Since the ear-pads do not cover the listener's
entire ears, over-heating after prolonged usage really isn't a problem. The
covering for the cushions is synthetic and closely resembles leather.
Additionally Roccat also provides cushions with velvet covering which can be
swapped in (this option is apparently only available in Europe, mind you). Our
main concern with regard to the Tit and comfort of the headset was related to
the stiff adjustment mechanism that makes it hard to properly set the headset
in place.
Supra-aural design means that the ear-pads
of the Kulo are small
Like all the other contenders you have the option to plug in
the Kulo to your computer via USB or 3.5mm jack. There is an in-line control
pod provided for controlling volume, but the stiff slider makes it difficult to
make minute changes to decibel levels. There is also a microphone for handling
communications while gaming. The Kulo also comes with a companion software
platform that can be used to help the headset reach its full potential. It has
a number of customization options for 7.1 virtual surround, though the
experience is marred by an unintuitive user interface.
The supra-aural design of the Kulo helps in terms of
comfort, though has the unfortunate side effect of being a detriment in 7.1
virtual surround sound for gaming. The audio from the headset comes across as
constricted, and with insufficient space to develop. Add to that the lack of
assistance from Dolby technologies (or anything of that sort). With the odds
stacked against it, the Kulo simply cannot keep up with the pack.
And the Best Gaming Headset
is…
Sennheiser PC 363D
If we look at only gaming performance, three contenders pull
ahead of the pack. The Sennheiser PC 363D, Razer Kraken 7.1 and SteelSeries
Siberia Elite all had excellent 7.1 virtual surround sound courtesy of either
Dolby technologies, or in the case of Razer, proprietary audio enhancement. But
when other factors are considered, a clear winner emerges. The Sennheiser PC
363D provided a great degree of comfort due to its “XXL” ear-cups, and the open
back design not only delivered a wide, natural soundstage, but also prevented
over-heating thanks to great ventilation.
Sennheiser PC 363D
Finally, a neutral tone allowed the Sennheiser headset to
excel when handling music as well. Taking overall performance into account, the
PC 363D turned out to be worthy of our Best Performance award.
Razer Kraken 7.1
When it came to the Best Value award, the Logitech G430 and
the Razer Kraken 7.1 were in the frame for consideration. The Logitech gaming
headset had a slight edge in terms of comfort thanks to its sporty ear-pad
cushion covering. But with proprietary audio technology on its side the Razer
Kraken 7.1 had much better gaming performance. In addition the customization
and calibration made available by Razer’s Synapse 2.0 software meant that the
Kraken 7.1 could be tweaked to significantly improve your gaming performance.
Specifications
- Model: Razer Kraken 7.1
- Driver Size: 40mm
- Headphone Design: Circumaural
- Headphone Type: Closed
- Headphone Impedance: 32 Ohms
- Headphone Frequency Response: 20Hz to 20,000Hz
- Microphone Frequency Response: 100Hz to 12,000Hz
- Microphone Impedance: N/A
- Headphone Sensitivity: 112 dB
- 3.5mm: No
- USB: Yes
- Dolby Headphone: N/A
- Dolby Pro Logic IIx: N/A
- Companion Software: Razer Synapse 2.0
- Weight: 340g
- Price: $169.90
|